Rhetoric and Politics

cheap cialis pill certified cialis cheap viagra in canada cialis buy drug buy generic cialis viagra buy 25mg viagra cheap viagra without prescription buy cheapest viagra on line purchase viagra cialis 10mg buying generic viagra cialis pills viagra from india cheapest sildenafil citrate cheap cialis no rx viagra india cialis bangkok viagra for order buy sildenafil internet buy generic viagra online buying cialis online where to order cialis tablet cialis find cialis no prescription required viagra cheap drug order cialis cheap online online pharmacy cialis cialis no rx order generic cialis price of cialis viagra soft drug viagra cheap viagra from uk order cialis no prescription order cheap viagra viagra drug order cheap cialis cheap cialis pharmacy best price for viagra cheap viagra from usa cost cialis cialis overnight shipping cheapest generic cialis online generic viagra online online viagra viagra sales cheap cialis in canada compare cialis prices online cialis online drug viagra online purchase discount cialis without prescription no rx viagra cialis overnight viagra uk cialis order cheap cialis from usa buying cialis cialis overnight delivery cialis in bangkok buy and purchase sildenafil online impotence treatment cheap price viagra viagra sale cheap cialis tablet drug cialis generic cialis online cheap viagra pharmacy find discount cialis online viagra malaysia cialis without a prescription buy cialis online cheap viagra rx buy no rx viagra cialis 20mg viagra in malaysia discount viagra online buy sildenafil cheap buy viagra low price buy cialis cialis cheap price cialis cheap generic viagra cialis canada low cost viagra buy cheap viagra cialis vs viagra order cialis from us cialis tablets find no rx cialis buy generic cialis online buy viagra overnight delivery cheapest cialis price buy cheapest cialis on line order cialis in canada viagra tablet viagra no online prescription find cheap cialis online viagra price order viagra no prescription cheap generic cialis buy viagra online cheap cialis uk cialis without rx generic cialis cheap viagra vs cialis order cialis on internet viagra tablets viagra purchase impotence drugs buy cialis generic cialis tablet cialis cheapest price order viagra from canada viagra generic cheap viagra from canada order cialis compare viagra prices online find cheap cialis impotence cure pfizer viagra find discount cialis cheapest cialis buy cialis from india impotence buy cheapest viagra online cialis side effects viagra order discount cialis online cialis in malaysia cialis in uk viagra in uk cialis online without prescription cialis online pharmacy order viagra buy viagra online viagra side effects cialis sale discount cialis no rx cheapest viagra find cialis order cialis no rx buy cialis low price buy viagra cheap drug cialis online purchase order discount viagra online 50 mg viagra 100 mg viagra 10mg cialis cost of cialis cheapest cialis prices buy discount viagra online cialis sales 50mg viagra cialis price buy viagra on internet cialis pill cheapest cialis online purchase viagra overnight delivery cheap cialis from canada cheapest viagra price cialis 20 mg buy sildenafil low cost order viagra without prescription buy viagra lowest price no prescription cialis order viagra on internet discount cialis overnight delivery cialis cheap drug viagra approved viagra no rx required compare viagra prices no rx cialis cheap cialis on internet buy viagra from india buy discount cialis online viagra pharmacy online order viagra from us cialis free delivery cialis for order buy cialis from canada viagra without rx viagra online review 10 mg cialis cheap viagra no rx cheapest viagra prices viagra prices cialis pharmacy order no rx cialis buy cialis in us buy cialis no prescription required order cialis from canada lowest price cialis cheap cialis internet online pharmacy viagra cheapest generic cialis generic drugs cialis india find cialis without prescription best price cialis buy viagra without prescription cheap cialis in uk where to buy viagra 20 mg cialis cheap cialis from uk buy sildenafil canada cialis no rx required cialis in us buy cialis overnight delivery cialis cheap price order cheap viagra online 20mg cialis buy cheap viagra online viagra internet viagra without prescription free cialis buy cialis us cialis buy buy viagra in canada order viagra cheap online find viagra without prescription viagra pills cheap cialis no prescription viagra online without prescription order generic viagra cialis discount viagra cheapest price purchase viagra no rx viagra no rx viagra cheap discount viagra overnight delivery sale cialis cialis pharmacy online purchase cialis without prescription pharmacy online cialis medication discount viagra buy cheap cialis impotence medication viagra medication find cialis on internet impotence pills cialis prices discount viagra without prescription cialis online cheap cialis online review find cheap viagra online buy viagra us purchase cialis online certified viagra where to order viagra buy cheapest viagra buy cialis internet order cialis online buy sildenafil online buy cialis cheap cheap viagra purchase cialis find discount viagra buy cialis on internet cialis buy online buy sildenafil online without a prescription viagra buy online order cheap cialis online viagra information no prescription viagra cost of viagra buy cialis in canada buy cialis online buy viagra cheapest generic viagra cialis us cialis australia fda approved cialis lowest price for viagra viagra bangkok cialis prescription cialis cost buy no rx cialis buy viagra internet viagra discount order viagra overnight delivery generic cialis viagra australia 25 mg viagra order viagra online viagra overnight cialis rx order cialis in us order viagra no rx order discount cialis online viagra vendors order viagra in us buy sildenafil in uk viagra us buy generic viagra viagra canada viagra no prescription viagra cheap price cheap viagra tablet viagra free delivery overnight viagra purchase viagra online find cheap viagra cialis malaysia best price viagra cialis free sample find viagra on internet cialis generic buy sildenafil in canada order cialis no prescription required cheapest viagra online purchase cialis no rx viagra in us order discount cialis cheap viagra internet free viagra cialis approved best price for cialis cialis from india find no rx viagra generic viagra viagra from canada viagra online pharmacy buy viagra from canada cheapest generic viagra online buy cheapest cialis discount cialis viagra overnight delivery cialis without prescription 100mg viagra cialis in australia price of viagra order cialis overnight delivery cheap viagra in uk buying generic cialis viagra pill buy cialis on line low cost cialis find discount viagra online buying viagra cheap cialis overnight delivery pharmacy cialis cheap viagra pill viagra prescription find viagra online buy cialis lowest price discount viagra no rx online cialis viagra free sample cheap viagra in usa find viagra cheap viagra online buy viagra no rx generic viagra cheap buy cialis without prescription buy viagra in us cheap viagra overnight delivery cheap cialis in usa cheap cialis online viagra order no rx viagra viagra soft tab find cialis online lowest price viagra cialis drug cialis vendors viagra online stores erectile dysfunction order viagra in canada buy viagra on line viagra overnight shipping viagra online cheap lowest price for cialis approved viagra pharmacy cialis 10 mg cialis no online prescription cialis purchase cialis from canada order cialis without prescription viagra for sale viagra in australia approved cialis pharmacy buy viagra generic buy sildenafil in spain find viagra no prescription required cialis no prescription buy viagra from us order viagra no prescription required cost viagra purchase viagra without prescription buy cialis no rx cialis cheap cialis internet tablet viagra cheap viagra on internet viagra cost pharmacy viagra cialis soft tab cialis information buy cheap cialis internet purchase cialis overnight delivery cheap cialis without prescription buy viagra no prescription required compare cialis prices buy cheap cialis online overnight cialis where to buy cialis cheap cialis buy cheap viagra internet buy discount cialis viagra buy drug cheap viagra no prescription buy sildenafil citrate buying viagra online buy discount viagra fda approved viagra cialis online stores cheap cialis tablets buy cheapest cialis online cheap viagra tablets order discount viagra sale viagra viagra online cialis for sale cialis soft viagra pharmacy buy cialis from us viagra without a prescription viagra in bangkok

When I woke up September 3, 2004, I had a splitting headache. Like many college undergrads having had too much alcohol the night before, I was ready to swear off the poison in hopes that the throbbing of my head would stop. Of course, no amount of sacrifice would make the temporary pain stop.

The morning would get much worse before I would begin to feel better. I had passed out on the couch of my living room as I watched states go red. In the way most politically active young people react, I had felt that the world had gone mad. My vote, already counting for very little, was at least part of a greater resistance. My state went blue, hardly a surprise considering I was living in Rhode Island. My state had said, “not us.” The nation as a whole said otherwise. I was disgusted, and my TV had stayed on, cheerfully (as it was relatively early still) informing me that the votes had been counted in other states.

My sense that a nightmare would end was wrong. My opinion of certain conservative members of my own family was called into question. I made my statement in the way such statements must be made: aloud. “I will never get so wrapped up in an election again.” As little as the statement did to my hangover, it became a litany in my life. 2006 came, and while I voted as I felt for Rhode Island’s open Senate seat, I could comfortably acknowledge the “other guy” as a decent and honorable man. I didn’t feel quite so emotionally attached, and it was good.

Now, in April of 2008, I find my litany challenged, not for the reasons I would have suspected, but out of a frustration with everything related. To be honest, the candidate I currently support was not my first choice, nor my second. I have learned to appreciate him for his depth and his understanding, but it did take some time.

I have read and sadly find myself agreeing with Al Gore when he bemoans the end of the Age of Reason. Part of this bitterness comes from the pains I felt so closely in 2004, as well as the pains I feel every time I hear of a friend going on a tour in Iraq. Some part of me still rages at Pennsylvania, Florida, and Ohio. Another part of me rages at my now Senator, John Kerry, for not being aggressive enough, for not playing Bush’s rhetorical game of chess. I’ve seen him in person twice now, and I can tell how much better he can be in person than he ever was on television. Another part of me suspects it wouldn’t have made a difference.

I will not suggest that the election was “stolen” or people who voted for Bush were somehow “uninformed.” Those I know who voted Republican were generally well informed, and there was certainly enough of them that it is certainly no fluke nor impossibility Bush won. He played fast pitch and Kerry just wasn’t quick enough.

I should also say what rankles most about these last four years is not the blood, the cost of gas, the sadness of the future. These could and probably would have happened no matter the victor. What rankles is the game. For the third time of my observation, George Bush took down an opponent not by actually addressing issues, but by repeating a false rhetoric and using media connections to further repeat these mistruths.

I studied rhetoric in college and the usage of the language to twist the reputations of good men struck me as anti-ethical. Arguments of “reality-based communities” openly admitted the old systems had been co-opted. Regardless of what was “true,” we had the media discussing unsubstantiated allegations fed to them. And when truths were discussed, it was a discussion not on the message, but on the telling. This was a distinction I felt and feel is very telling. Discussing the telling is easier, “Kerry just can’t loosen up. Bush appears more relaxed.” Messages appeared meaningless. The election in 2004 or, for that matter, 2000 had ceased to be about issues at all. It was the straight-laced Ivy League Liberal Elites vs the down-to-earth Texas Rancher. The reality of either side rarely entered the discussion.

2006 was in some ways a break. In Rhode Island, the discussion and decision for the key Senate seat was straight forward, a single variable equation: which party would the winner caucus with. The victor had nothing but good things to say about Lincoln Chafee, the incumbent, aside from that single variable. The challenger, Sheldon Whitehouse won.

In this presidential cycle, we have seen these new old systems come into play once again. It’s beyond personal attacks; it’s only personality. When the field was wide, there was at least some discussion on the Democrat side of issues. Even then, it was beginning. “Barack Obama speaks so eloquently,” as if eloquence was something amazing in a politician. I will be the first to say he is by far the best public speaker either party has seen in about twenty years, but what was more important was where he stood on the issues. It turns out, he was and is strong, stronger than those I supported beforehand. But, almost more importantly, he tends not to sling mud.

We have been presented with a unique and interesting experience as citizens of the United States in this age. Three candidates, differing on many issues, all being constantly torn down by each other and by the media. No one is safe, and the “positive” stories are barely mentioned. The media coverage of all three is antagonistic.

There are good stories for all three, great ones even. McCain’s views of the war should be presented alongside the fact that his own son is presented with the consequences of his decisions. He constantly makes decisions that are almost impossibly hard for any parent. Hillary has seen how to run this country well. She has been directly exposed to the administration that has seen the smoothest economy since the New Deal. She also has one of the best advisors any President could want, regardless of how his personal decisions have polarized the nation. Obama has a consistent message and history that he doesn’t need to explain away.

What of these three do we see: McCain’s gaffes, his “senior moments,” his hundred year comment. Hillary’s attacks, her tears, her flawed memories. Obama’s pastor, his “bitter” comment, the “cult of personality.” All things that must be taken into account, but hardly the measure of a man, or a candidate, or a platform. What should we see? Their stands, maybe.

When McCain said he intended to stay in Iraq indefinitely, it was not a prescription for endless war, but a very nuanced standpoint that, if you follow an interventionist view on foreign policy, makes sense. It would be a mistake to simply walk away and assume everything would go to plan. It is a stance that both Hillary and Obama would do well to honestly address. We don’t have that discussion, one about a defining feature of present and future U.S. foreign policy.

When Hillary talks about her experience, both in Senate and as the First Lady, is does the truth a disservice by not discussing it. Her role in both was not minor, and she has very strong opinions on various topics, such as health care. We talk about her experience, thankfully we even talk a little bit about her proposals. We don’t talk about why her proposals have changed so much in eight years. We don’t talk about where the money of her campaign comes from. Where is the nuanced discussion of health care in America? Do we have to have it from Michael Moore?

Obama’s pastor was angry, maybe even justifiably so, but we never discussed his possible justification, just the way the message was delivered. We held Obama to his pastor’s behavior without a discussion of the message. His bitter comment? Well, have we really looked at if the people living in rural America are bitter? According to my time in rural Pennsylvania, they are and justifiably so. Where is the discussion among the candidates and the media about a growing class distinction? We mention “the two Americas,” but it is a talking point, not a discussion.

Among the candidates, we begin to see hope. At least, in one candidate. The rhetoric of both McCain and Hillary is similar, the other guy is bad. Some assertion is made, veracity and nuance be damned. Obama is not immune to these problems, but he spends far more time discussing problems and solutions to issues. The cult of personality related to him is the hope of a new day, one in which it isn’t about personality, but a change in the discussion. That’s a cult I can support.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.